Skip to content 
Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls always vanish fast at my table. Soft, golden, and brushed with warm garlic butter, they bring comfort to the holiday meal. In my kitchen, the rolls are usually gone before the turkey makes it to the table.
David can never resist sneaking the first one, still hot from the pan. The girls crowd around to help roll the dough, leaving flour everywhere, and John always declares they taste better than bakery rolls. My little secret is mixing cottage cheese into the dough, which makes them extra tender and a bit richer. Susan even asks me to bake an extra batch each year because she wants leftovers for breakfast.
If you’re after a side dish that feels festive yet simple, these garlic butter bread rolls with cottage cheese are sure to earn a spot at your Thanksgiving feast.
Table of Contents
Why Garlic Butter Bread Rolls Belong on Your Thanksgiving Table
Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls have become a tradition in my home. They are soft, golden, and brushed with warm garlic butter, the kind of rolls that vanish before the turkey even reaches the table. They bring a cozy feeling to the meal, and I love watching how quickly everyone grabs one.
David says the holiday doesn’t feel complete without them. John calls them “restaurant rolls,” and the girls can’t stop pulling them apart, giggling as the steam escapes. What makes them different is the cottage cheese I add to the dough. It keeps them tender and light, while also giving a richer taste that surprises guests every year.
On a table filled with casseroles, roasted vegetables, and desserts, these buttery rolls still stand out. They aren’t just bread. They are the piece of the meal that brings everyone together, basket after basket, until not a crumb is left.
Ingredients for Fluffy Garlic Butter Rolls
When I think about Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls, the first thing I do is pull out the ingredients. They are simple, but together they create rolls that are soft, golden, and packed with flavor.
Core ingredients for homemade dinner rolls
For the dough, I reach for flour, yeast, warm milk, sugar, eggs, and butter. The yeast makes the dough rise high and gives me fluffy bread rolls instead of heavy ones. A little sugar wakes up the yeast and adds balance. The milk and eggs make the dough richer, while butter keeps it tender. When they come out of the oven, these homemade dinner rolls are the kind that melt in your mouth.
Garlic herb butter topping
Of course, the magic happens with the topping. Melted butter mixed with garlic and a sprinkle of parsley turns simple bread into garlic herb butter rolls. I brush some on right as they leave the oven so the butter soaks deep inside. Then I add more at the table, giving everyone glossy, warm buttery garlic rolls that disappear fast.
The cottage cheese twist
Here’s the secret that sets these rolls apart. I fold cottage cheese into the dough, and it transforms them. Instead of being heavy, they come out light and pillowy. The flavor is slightly tangy, which works beautifully with the garlic butter. The result is soft dinner rolls that are rich without being overwhelming. David now says these are the best Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls I’ve ever made, and I have to agree.
Step-by-Step Recipe – Garlic Butter Bread Rolls
Making Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls has become one of my favorite holiday rituals. The process is simple, but each step feels special when the kitchen is full of chatter, little hands, and the smell of warm yeast dough.
Step 1: Mixing the dough
I start by warming some milk and stirring in sugar and yeast. After a few minutes, the mixture turns foamy, which means it is ready. Then I add eggs, melted butter, and a scoop of cottage cheese. That cottage cheese blends in so well, giving the dough richness without making it heavy. Bit by bit, I stir in flour until the dough begins to come together.
Kneading is where the fun begins. Lily and Sophie love pressing their palms into the dough, leaving tiny floury fingerprints everywhere. The dough changes as I work it, going from sticky to smooth, ready to rise into fluffy bread rolls.
Step 2: The first rise
Once the dough feels soft and elastic, I place it in a greased bowl and cover it with a towel. After about an hour, it doubles in size. John always peeks under the towel and says the same thing every year: “Now that’s dough ready for greatness.” He’s right. This step is what gives us the light texture of true homemade dinner rolls.
Step 3: Shaping the rolls
The dough gets punched down gently, then divided into even pieces. The girls take charge here, rolling little balls of dough with proud smiles. Not every roll comes out perfectly round, but that’s part of the charm. Arranged in a buttered pan, they look like a tray of promises waiting to bake.
Step 4: The second rise
I cover the pan again and let the rolls puff up for another thirty minutes. This second rise makes them soft and airy. Placed close together, they grow into the pull-apart style that makes garlic herb butter rolls so inviting.
Step 5: Baking
The rolls bake until their tops turn golden brown and the house smells like pure comfort. The moment I pull them out, David is already standing by with the brush. We coat the hot rolls with melted butter mixed with garlic, watching it seep into every crevice.
Step 6: Finishing with garlic butter
Just before serving, I brush them again, this time with butter and parsley for a glossy finish. The rolls shine on the table, soft on the inside and fragrant on the outside. They never last long. David always claims the first one, and the kids follow quickly, leaving the basket half empty before dinner even starts.
Tips for Perfect Buttery Garlic Rolls Every Time
Every year I bake Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls, and every year I pick up a few more tricks. These rolls are simple, but small details are what turn them into the star of the meal.
Let the dough rise properly
The first rise is where the magic happens. If the dough doubles in size, you’ll get fluffy bread rolls that feel light and airy. I always cover the bowl with a towel and let it sit in a cozy spot. It takes patience, but that patience is the reason my soft dinner rolls bake up so tender.
Shape them evenly
When the dough is ready, I divide it into pieces and roll them smooth. Even shaping means each roll bakes the same, which keeps the basket looking beautiful. The girls sometimes rush, but I remind them that even little details make better homemade dinner rolls.
Brush while hot
The moment the pan comes out of the oven, I brush the tops with garlic butter. This step makes the rolls glisten and locks flavor into every bite. For true buttery garlic rolls, I save a little butter and brush them again just before serving. That final touch is what makes garlic herb butter rolls impossible to resist.
Use cottage cheese in the dough
The biggest secret in my recipe for Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls is cottage cheese. Mixed right into the dough, it makes the rolls lighter, softer, and adds a mild tang. Guests are always surprised when I tell them, but once they taste it, they understand why these Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls never last long.
Variations You’ll Love
The best thing about Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls is how flexible they are. Once you know the base recipe, it’s easy to play around with flavors and shapes. These variations keep the rolls exciting, and they always disappear just as fast as the original.
Cheesy garlic butter rolls
When my family wants extra indulgence, I tuck mozzarella or cheddar into the dough. As the rolls bake, the cheese melts and creates pockets of flavor. The basket of buttery garlic rolls is usually empty before I can even set the turkey down. For me, this cheesy version proves why Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls are the real star of the meal.
Herb-infused garlic rolls
Fresh herbs like rosemary, thyme, or sage turn the classic into fragrant garlic herb butter rolls. I brush them generously before serving, and the smell is pure holiday comfort. John insists that the herb version of Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls is the only one worthy of his plate piled high with turkey and gravy.
Pull-apart fluffy bread rolls
Instead of spacing the dough balls, I pack them tightly in a round pan. They rise into pull-apart bread that tears easily at the table. These fluffy bread rolls look impressive in the middle of the feast, and Susan always sneaks “just one more piece.” It’s proof that even a simple tweak makes Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls unforgettable.
Cottage cheese and chive rolls
Since cottage cheese is my secret ingredient, sometimes I stir in chopped chives too. The combination makes soft dinner rolls that are savory and light at the same time. David likes to use these as slider buns for leftover turkey the next day, which means I have to bake a double batch of Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls.
Serving Ideas for Thanksgiving Garlic Butter Rolls
There are endless ways to enjoy Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls, and in my family, we’ve probably tried them all. These rolls never sit untouched on the table — they’re always the first basket to empty, no matter what else is served.
With soups and stews
Nothing comforts more than soup paired with warm bread. A basket of soft dinner rolls dipped into hearty stew or creamy chowder makes even a simple meal taste like a feast. David always says the garlic butter gives soup “a little extra hug.” That’s why I often bake an extra pan of Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls just for the night before Thanksgiving.
Alongside the main feast
The real magic happens at dinner. A plate loaded with turkey, stuffing, and cranberry sauce always feels complete with buttery garlic rolls tucked on the side. They soak up gravy better than anything else. John insists that Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls deserve their own spot next to the turkey because they’re just as important.
As sliders with leftovers
Leftovers are where these rolls shine again. Split open, the fluffy bread rolls make perfect sliders for turkey, cheese, and cranberry sauce. Susan likes to pack a few of these sandwiches to take home, which means I always save some Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls from the big meal.
Holiday centerpiece
When arranged in a round pan and baked close together, the rolls turn into pull-apart garlic herb butter rolls. Brushed with parsley butter, they look beautiful in the center of the table. Guests always ask how I made them so pretty, and the truth is it’s just the same dough shaped a little differently.
Kid-friendly snack
Of course, not every roll makes it to dinner. The girls sneak into the kitchen, tearing into the homemade dinner rollswhile they’re still warm. By the time guests arrive, a few of the Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls are already missing, and I can’t blame them — they’re impossible to resist.
Storing & Reheating Garlic Butter Bread Rolls
No matter how many pans I make, there are never enough Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls at our table. On the rare occasion that a few are left, I make sure they’re stored properly so they taste just as good the next day.
Storing at room temperature
Fresh from the oven, the rolls stay soft for up to two days if kept in an airtight container. I line the container with parchment to keep the bottoms from sticking, then cover the rolls with a clean towel before closing the lid. This helps the fluffy bread rolls stay tender without drying out.
Freezing for later
When I want to get ahead of holiday cooking, I bake an extra batch of Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls and freeze them. Once cooled, I wrap each roll tightly in plastic and store them in a freezer bag. That way, I can pull out a few at a time, and they taste almost as fresh as the day they were baked.
Reheating in the oven
The best way to bring rolls back to life is in a warm oven. I place the soft dinner rolls on a baking sheet, cover them loosely with foil, and heat at 325°F for about ten minutes. They come out warm and pillowy, just like they were when first baked. David swears this step makes the rolls taste even better the next day.
Reheating in the microwave
For a quicker option, I wrap one or two homemade dinner rolls in a damp paper towel and heat them for fifteen seconds. The moisture keeps them soft, though they don’t get the same crisp top as oven-baked. Still, it’s perfect when the girls want a roll with their soup and don’t want to wait.
Adding more garlic butter
Before serving leftovers, I always brush them with a fresh layer of garlic butter. This turns simple reheated rolls back into shiny, fragrant buttery garlic rolls. With one brush of butter and parsley, they become garlic herb butter rolls worthy of another spot on the holiday table.
If you enjoy how cottage cheese makes these rolls tender, you’ll love the way it transforms baked goods in this peach and blueberry loaf recipe.
Thanksgiving Garlic Butter Bread Rolls with Cottage Cheese
Ingredients
Equipment
Method
- In a large bowl, combine warm milk, sugar, and yeast. Let it sit until foamy.
- Add eggs, melted butter, and cottage cheese. Mix until combined.
- Stir in flour and salt, adding a little at a time, until dough forms.
- Knead the dough on a floured surface until smooth and elastic, about 8–10 minutes.
- Place the dough in a greased bowl, cover, and let rise until doubled in size (about 1 hour).
- Punch down the dough, divide into equal portions, and roll into balls. Place in a greased baking dish.
- Cover and let the rolls rise again for 30 minutes.
- Bake at 350°F (175°C) for 20–25 minutes or until golden brown.
- While baking, prepare garlic butter: melt butter, stir in garlic and parsley.
- Brush rolls with garlic butter immediately after baking, then again before serving.
Notes
Rolls can be frozen after baking; reheat in the oven and brush with fresh garlic butter.
Perfect served with Thanksgiving turkey, soups, or as leftover sliders.
FAQs About Garlic Butter Bread Rolls
Even though I’ve baked Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls for years, I still get questions about them every holiday. Here are some of the most common ones.
Is it better to butter rolls before or after baking?
I always brush garlic butter on right after baking. The heat helps the butter soak into the bread, giving you moist and flavorful soft dinner rolls. A second brush before serving makes them shine like true buttery garlic rolls. Some bakers butter before baking, but in my kitchen, after baking gives the best results.
How to make garlic butter step by step?
Garlic butter is simple. I melt butter in a small pan, stir in minced garlic, and let it cook gently for a minute. A sprinkle of parsley finishes it off. This is what transforms plain rolls into irresistible garlic herb butter rolls. It’s also the step that makes Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls fill the house with that holiday smell.
How do you make garlic bread at home?
Garlic bread starts with a good base. I often use homemade dinner rolls or even slices of leftover bread. Spread with garlic butter, then toast until golden, and you’ve got a quick version of fluffy bread rolls turned into garlic bread. Still, nothing beats fresh Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls when it comes to flavor and texture.
What is the best bread to use for garlic bread?
Any bread works, but soft bread makes the best garlic bread. That’s why I prefer using Thanksgiving garlic butter bread rolls. Their tender crumb absorbs the butter beautifully, and the flavor feels homemade. Guests often say the rolls taste better than any loaf of garlic bread from the store.
